by Ruby Henley
The Left is crying out, “lies, lies, the Memo is filled with lies!” Let’s go back and prove to the Left that their cohorts in the Mainstream Media helped to back up the Memo.
I want to thank Tracy Beanz for her thorough video, which led me to do this report.
We will start with the following www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-russia-dossier/ex-british-spy-paid-168000-for-trump-dossier-u-s-firm-discloses-idUSKBN1D15XH?utm_campaign=trueAnthem:+Trending+Content&utm_content=59fa777204d30146d37b79bc&utm_medium=trueAnthem&utm_source=twitter
- Ex-British spy paid $168,000 for Trump dossier, US firm discloses. Although it was public knowledge that Fusion GPS paid for the work, the amount had not been disclosed. Fusion GPS hired former MI6 officer Christopher Steele to collect information about Trump and his advisers.
Fusion GPS’ statement said it had told Congress about how $168,000 was paid last year to Orbis Business Intelligence, Steele’s company. The money paid to Orbis was taken from $1.02 million it received in fees and expenses from the Perkins Coie law firm, the statement said. The law firm represented the Democratic National Committee and Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign, although initial research by Fusion into Trump and other Republican primary candidates was commissioned by a conservative website.
Wow! That tells us who paid for the dossier…plain and simple. Congress knew it, too.
2.The making of the bombshell Trump Dossier Dominating the News.
In September of 2015, the “Times” said a Republican donor hired a DC Investigative firm to compile a report on Trump scandals. As Trump went from primary hopeful to GOP nominee, Fusion GPS continue working on the report. At that time Hillary Clinton began footing the bill in hope of derailing Trump.
3.THIS IS HUGE! A US counterintelligence task force was established by the CIA in 2016 to investigate possible Russian funding of President-elect Donald Trump’s presidential campaign, the BBC reported on Friday.
The task force included the FBI, the Treasury and Justice Departments, the CIA, the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, and the National Security Agency (NSA). It was set up after the director of the CIA, John Brennan, received a recording of a conversation about money from the Kremlin going into Trump’s campaign coffers, the BBC’s Paul Wood reported.
John Brennan was a big instigator in moving all of this along. Ask yourself where he received a recording of that conversation, because if it had been authentic, it would have been evidence, would it not? Talk about lies!
4.FBI, 5 other agencies probe possible covert Kremlin aid to Trump.
The FBI and five other law enforcement and intelligence agencies have collaborated for months in an investigation into Russian attempts to influence the November election, including whether money from the Kremlin covertly aided President-elect Donald Trump, two people familiar with the matter said.The agencies involved in the inquiry are the FBI, the CIA, the National Security Agency, the Justice Department, the Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network and representatives of the director of national intelligence, the sources said. A key mission of the six-agency group has been to examine who financed the email hacks of the Democratic National Committee and Clinton campaign chairman John Podesta. The London-based transparency group WikiLeaks released the emails last summer and in October.
This just shows all the time and money that went into a Deep State plan to oust President Trump. It is a disgrace. Our entire Intelligence community participated. On top of that, we know now the DNC emails were leaked by someone on the inside. We believe that person to be Seth Rich.
5.Obama has the dossier.
Earlier Thursday, Vice President Biden confirmed that he and Obama were briefed on the unverified claims contained in the dossier. The information had apparently been circulating among journalists and politicians in Washington for several months, but was never reported because the contents of the dossier could not be verified. CNN first reported on Tuesday that Trump had received a summary of the claims. Soon after, Buzzfeed News posted the 35-page dossier, which was allegedly compiled by a former British intelligence officer, in its entirety.
The whole entire city of Washington DC read and believe the claims made in a false dossier!
6.Trump ‘compromising’ claims: How and why did we get here? Fisa first mentioned here.
The taskforce included six agencies or departments of government. Dealing with the domestic, US, side of the inquiry, were the FBI, the Department of the Treasury, and the Department of Justice. For the foreign and intelligence aspects of the investigation, there were another three agencies: the CIA, the Office of the Director of National Intelligence and the National Security Agency, responsible for electronic spying. Lawyers from the National Security Division in the Department of Justice then drew up an application. They took it to the secret US court that deals with intelligence, the Fisa court, named after the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. They wanted permission to intercept the electronic records from two Russian banks. Their first application, in June, was rejected outright by the judge. They returned with a more narrowly drawn order in July and were rejected again. Finally, before a new judge, the order was granted, on 15 October, three weeks before election day. The investigation was ongoing into the election. During that period, the leader of the Democrats in the Senate, Harry Reid, wrote to the director of the FBI, accusing him of holding back “explosive information” about Mr Trump. Mr Reid sent his letter after getting an intelligence briefing, along with other senior figures in Congress. Only eight people were present: the chairs and ranking minority members of the House and Senate intelligence committees, and the leaders of the Democratic and Republican parties in Congress, the “gang of eight” as they are sometimes called. Normally, senior staff attend “gang of eight” intelligence briefings, but not this time. The Congressional leaders were not even allowed to take notes.
So we see Congress knew!
7. Clapper knew of the warrant, so he perjured himself when saying he did not. Intel chiefs presented Trump with claims of Russian efforts to compromise him.
Classified documents presented last week to President Obama and President-elect Trump included allegations that Russian operatives claim to have compromising personal and financial information about Mr. Trump, multiple US officials with direct knowledge of the briefings tell CNN.
The allegations were presented in a two-page synopsis that was appended to a report on Russian interference in the 2016 election. The allegations came, in part, from memos compiled by a former British intelligence operative, whose past work US intelligence officials consider credible. The FBI is investigating the credibility and accuracy of these allegations, which are based primarily on information from Russian sources, but has not confirmed many essential details in the memos about Mr. Trump.The classified briefings last week were presented by four of the senior-most US intelligence chiefs — Director of National Intelligence James Clapper, FBI Director James Comey, CIA Director John Brennan, and NSA Director Admiral Mike Rogers.
And the web of lies were spun and spun all based on a fake dossier.
8.Clinton campaign, DNC paid for research that to led to Russia dossier! FBI PAID, TOO.
Some of Steele’s allegations began circulating in Washington in the summer of 2016 as the FBI launched its counterintelligence investigation into possible connections between Trump associates and the Kremlin. Around that time, Steele shared some of his findings with the FBI. After the election, the FBI agreed to pay Steele to continue gathering intelligence about Trump and Russia, but the bureau pulled out of the arrangement after Steele was publicly identified in news reports.
COMEY, THE BACKSTABBING LIAR. TRUMP KNEW HE WAS THAT AND MORE.
frameborder=’0′ webkitallowfullscreen mozallowfullscreen allowfullscreen></iframe>
President Trump suggested Thursday that the FBI may have had a hand in creating an intelligence dossier that alleged ties between Russia and Trump’s presidential campaign. “Workers of firm involved with the discredited and Fake Dossier take the 5th. Who paid for it, Russia, the FBI or the Dems (or all)?” Trump wrote on Twitter. The compendium of information about Trump, much of it unproven, was produced by a former British intelligence agent last year, mostly before Trump won the 2016 election. Officials have said the FBI has confirmed some of the information and rejected other parts, and caution that it may be impossible to verify or disprove the rest. Trump has vigorously denied allegations in the document that the Russian government has collected compromising information about him and was engaged in an active effort to assist his campaign.The Washington Post has previously reported that the FBI agreed in October 2016 to pay the dossier’s author, Christopher Steele, for further work that might help its own investigation into Russian election activities.
9.U.S. intel officials probe ties between Trump adviser and Kremlin.
The activities of Trump adviser Carter Page, who has extensive business interests in Russia, have been discussed with senior members of Congress during recent briefings about suspected efforts by Moscow to influence the presidential election, the sources said. After one of those briefings, Senate minority leader Harry Reid wrote FBI Director James Comey, citing reports of meetings between a Trump adviser (a reference to Page) and “high ranking sanctioned individuals” in Moscow over the summer as evidence of “significant and disturbing ties” between the Trump campaign and the Kremlin that needed to be investigated by the bureau. Some of those briefed were “taken aback” when they learned about Page’s contacts in Moscow, viewing them as a possible back channel to the Russians that could undercut U.S. foreign policy, said a congressional source familiar with the briefings but who asked for anonymity due to the sensitivity of the subject. The source added that U.S. officials in the briefings indicated that intelligence reports about the adviser’s talks with senior Russian officials close to President Vladimir Putin were being “actively monitored and investigated.”
Is this a laugh or not? Carter Page has been proven “not guilty.” He was a simple volunteer in the Trump campaign. He life was ruined by this. Comey must have been flying high by all of these lies!But Senator Grassley caught on to all of it, and sent him a long letter questioning him about if the FBI helped pay for the dossier. Comey should have been fired a long time ago. Just like Mueller should be now.
10.Faced with libel lawsuit, dossier drafter Christopher Steele hedges on linking Trump to Russia
Christopher Steele, the former British spy who fueled an ongoing investigation into President Trump’s administration, was a lot more confident of his charges when he wrote his now-notorious 2016 dossier than he is today in defending it in a libel lawsuit. While Mr. Steele stated matter-of-factly in his dossier that collusion between Mr. Trump and the Russian government took place, he called it only “possible” months later in court filings. While he confidently referred to “trusted” sources inside the Kremlin, in court he referred to the dossier’s “limited intelligence.” In recent weeks, the dossier of opposition research has taken on added importance in the debate over the FBI and special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation into suspected Russia coordination and whether it is biased against Trump people. Congressional Republicans are demanding that the FBI explain how the deeply contested, Democrat-financed document took on such importance in a major government investigation. Mr. Steele wrote 35 pages of memos in which he said Trump aides were part of a vast conspiracy with Moscow to interfere in the election against Hillary Clinton. The unverified charges were spread by Fusion GPS, the Washington-based political research firm that first commissioned the report. Mr. Steele bragged to Mother Jones magazine that he started the Mueller investigation by convincing FBI agents that summer about the credibility of his dossier. It was later revealed that the campaign of Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton helped fund the dossier, meaning that in essence her paid agent was spreading unsubstantiated charges to get to the FBI to investigate her opponent, critics say. Now that Mr. Steele ust defend those charges in a London courtroom, his confidence level has shifted down several notches.
Republicans have pressed the FBI to disclose how it relied on an unproven document to investigate Mr. Trump and possibly to obtain surveillance warrants. In public, the FBI and Justice Department have declined to answer such questions.
The House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence has yet to release information it obtained from the FBI under threat of holding the bureau in contempt of Congress. Members asked Deputy FBI Director Andrew McCabe about it on Tuesday during seven hours of closed-door testimony.
I think I can stop here. The Left can say, “lies” if they choose. However, the mainstream media in this instance backs up the MEMO. In my opinion, James Comey is at the helm in this assault on our Judicial System and the stalking of a sitting US President. Comey led the whole witch hunt, and when he let Hillary Clinton go free of leaking classified intelligence on her home server, he did it as he felt she would be the next President. And if she owed him, he would be sitting high forever. Thank God, He intervened by helping President Trump to oust this whole evil plot against the United States.
Now, the Judicial System must do the right thing for the American people and the President of the United States and end the Mueller investigation once and for all!
57 thoughts on “Proving The Memo With Mainstream Media – Spelling It Out For The Left – FACTS DO NOT LIE.”
I see someone’s scared of ‘the Left’ loL!
BTW the Left are right about the FBI and the US government in general. The FBI needs to be abolished, along with the NSA and CIA and DEA.
Crazylegs, I am not scared of the Left! Absolutely not. I am trying to prove ….period….to anyone with a brain the MEMO is only filled with facts that have been documented by mainstream media. Wow, if I were Comey, I would be hiding in my closet.
Here’s your problem, you believe the lying propaganda media.
Give me a break. They actually did a good job in documentation….at least the ones who did not cohort with Clinton.
That was an excellent report Ruby, but you are always going to have detractor on the left. Crazylegs thinks the memo is fake!
Oh, boy, Crazylegs is crazy! Thanks for that info.
And when did the neo-Left make this announcement about these agencies?
The DINOs and RINOs were working together, the left/right paradigm is dead, Trump killed them both.
My cat explained it to me because, according to Nancy Pelosi, the American people are too stupid to understand anything unless they’re told what to understand, and John McCain agrees…so I asked my cat.
Right now, it is more accurate to call them the “Good” and the “Bad/Ugly”…or the “White Hats” and the “Black Hats.” Actually the bottom line is we can all be divided now as either “Luciferians” or “Christians”…..when I say “Christian” I mean do you believe that God sent Jesus Christ to earth to free mankind from the slavery of Lucifer? Do you believe that Christ actually made a blood sacrifice for mankind. In doing that, he opened a portal from this earth straight to God’s realm. If one accepts his sacrifice and believes in what he said, then one has to practice what Christ taught here on earth. You cannot straddle the fence. You must take your place now on the battlefield. You must die in Christ when your day comes.
Smart Cat! Make sure u post his updates!
Let there be no doubt that these Leftist/NeoBolsheviks will kill millions of us if given the chance. It is important to fight them to our utmost abilities. Notice everything the left says is a lie, especially Obama, but THEY zoom in on every little exaggeration Trump makes!
Mac, Trump has so much on him. I just did a report and it should be up tomorrow.
Yup, no one is clean, especially a Billionaire Real Estate investor/developer. I assume you have his and his son-in-laws Soros past Soros connections.
It is important that we git them out and dilute them while exposing Obama/Clinton and the Deep State’s illegal activities. I am sure whatever Trump has done in the past pales to the crimes of Clinton/Obama/Podesta and the rest of the Deep State. Podesta’s emails, Seth Rich and Monica Petersen, let alone Vegas, MUST be revealed!
Keep up the Good Work Girl, Surely you will be recognized in the next world if not this one!
Also do NOT git discouraged if you git a story or two wrong. THEY plant minefields of misinformation to discredit investigators big time!
Mac, my next story is on Seth Rich. I am researching now.
U truly are fearless. Hannity dropped it like a hot potato. A CCW AND Armed Body Guards!
It’ll be interesting to see what connection with the Paki IT people you come up with.
Insure also u git a good run down of the Podesta emails. So far we know that they contain a direct treat against the DNC leakers, child pedo buzzwords which look terribly like Satanic ritual abuse and perhaps even murder and lastly Satanic ceremonies with the “Spirit Cooking” .
I also think Uranium 1 is in it but can’t say for sure. So much corruption and I have such a little brain! Who can truly grasp it ALL???!!!
Also let me add it takes someone with the inside info to take these Scum on. Trump has made and lost Billions. He knows the game and isn’t totally clean. Neither was Saul, but he became PAUL!
Trump gotta be snow white clean compared to the Progressive Machine. I highly doubt there is a body count associated with him. Clinton and Obama definitely!
BRAVO, MAC. YOU JUST DESCRIBED OUR PRESIDENT PERFECTLY.
I am not sure who to believe about all this. I can stay focused on the fact that I don’t like the Clintons Obamas and Bush jr and sr. I am glad that something is pulling us out of their dealings. I never trusted them and I could see how they were working together. I know they are very dangerous and powerful and they are pissed I know they could start hurting people not that they haven’t already. I am sure Trump is more like them than me but I can appreciate that he has made the swamp livid. I voted for Ron Paul against Obama. I consider myself more libertarian so a lot of stuff is not going the way I want it to. It is kind of fun seeing the dems and rhinos continue to melt down that almost makes not getting what I want worth it. Except I ,know it could be dangerous.
WorkingGirl, I am not going to call you workingpoor. You are a workinggirl and a smart one at that. Remember that movie with Melanie Griffith…she finally hit it big. You will one day, too. Yes, we Patriots are in a lot of danger right now. I just did a report that probably will put me at high risk, but I had to do it. Trump is not your ordinary President, and we must give him that. He is literally risking his life.
Girl, WHEN do you Sleep? Proper rest is important to keep a clear head and maintain the fight against these Satanic Scum! In the military it is called the Crew Rest schedule.
Mac, I have insomnia unfortunately. I fall asleep when I do sleep at the computer….wake up with it in my hands. Some days I put it down and take care of my home, go out to the doctors, things like that. But really and truly my heart and mind are right here most of the time.
I know where you are comin from. I almost hope that THEY will begin the Chi-Com type of control over the internet so I can git some rest. Till then I shall NOT rest!
Thank you for your thoughtful reply Ruby. BTW I love your name. You can also call me Lisa. I have been standing against what is going on since Bush sr was in office. People have called me crazy and all kinds of other things. It was like a nightmare that I could not wake up from and it just kept getting worse. I have stayed in the trenches fighting against this NWO stuff as best as I could. By avoiding all the policies they were putting out it made me poor but I still knew I was standing for what was right. My reward is that it is starting to change and people are starting to see what I and people like you have been pointing out to them. I wrote a letter thanking Mr. Trump. It is the first time I have ever written to a president. I was always afraid to write to a president because I would not be thanking them. I already knew that they could squash me like a little bug not that they weren’t already doing that with their policies. Now that I am much older I feel like my grand children have a chance to live in the light. All my struggling has been worth it. I swept the floors in some pretty dirty places trying to keep my head above water. I lost my home, car and bank accounts due to what they did and my not being willing to comply. I would love to read and share your report can you put up a link?
Lisa, IWB just published it. These times are the most difficult to discern, but you and I are ahead of the game. Like most here, we have been given a wisdom from God that everyone does not have. We are rich in spirit, and now is our time. President Trump has been placed at the helm in America to bring the truth to the masses. Just like this FISA MEMO release, those who have eyes to see and ears to hear can now begin to see the truth. It is a step forward, but, Lisa, it is only a baby step. We have so far to go, and you and I are so far ahead of most people. However, IWB is filled with people like us, and if I did not have this place, I would be nuts….more than I already am. We will continue to gather here, and IWB is committed to us…to give us this forum to speak and share. So glad we ae all together.
G-d bless u Lisa. I’ve known it has been dirty since JFK got wacked. However with Bush II’s roll over for the Donkey Congress and his glee in doin so, I have had NO doubt since. How anyone with one eye and one ear can NOT see the Truth is amassing. Must be blinded by Satan! End Times most likely be acomin!
Good analysis. None of us know the Truth. Only we have been fed lies by da Bushes/Clintons and Obama’s Deep State for years now for the Globalist benefit and the destruction of America!
I too am more of a libertarian, but we must not be purist and take what scrapes we can git. So far Trump has delivered or has made a serious attempt to deliver on ALL his campaign promises. A first since Reagan. And even Reagan couldn’t successfully fight da Deep State and got shot and most likely drugged and manipulated by Bush for his efforts!
Mac, i just did a new report, and I now believe Trump is in great danger.
I predict he will git Heart Attacked or Stroked Out. Pence is the Globalist replacement puppet when da times comes.
The media is focused on his health and not a word about da HildeBeast who was dyin before our very eyes! THEY can induce these things easily. Now it seems THEY can kill you in your sleep. Most likely same electro magnetic principles!
That sums it up nicely. But hey, Democrats can’t be bothered by facts, their too busy scheming up ways to undermine the president. Nice job Ruby!
Thanks dogity. You are a good friend.
Rep. Matt Gaetz Explains The Entire TEAM OBAMA Corrupt FISA Scheme In less then 3 Minutes
Press conference after memo release
Excellent summary by congressman Gaetz! When you hear it put like that it really brings home the seriousness of this crime.
The Media are Just as Complicit In The DOJ Corruption and FISA Abuse
Cristopher Steele Testimony in British Court, July/2017:
“The journalists initially briefed at the end of September 2016 by the Second Defendant (Steele) and Fusion at Fusion’s instruction were from the New York Times, the Washington Post, Yahoo News, the New Yorker and CNN. The second defendant subsequently participated in further meetings at Fusion’s instruction with Fusion and the New York Times, the Washington Post, and Yahoo News, which took place in mid-October 2016. In each of those cases the breifing was done verbally in person. “In addition, and again at Fusion’s instruction, in late October 2016 the second defendant briefed a journalist from Mother Jones by Skype” – Cristopher Steele
1. Christopher Steele was meeting with journalists, the journalists were writing articles;
2. the FBI was leaking to media and simultaneously citing those same articles as underlying evidence to support their counterintelligence investigations;
3. all of this was used to validate the investigative documents the FBI was receiving from Christopher Steele;
4. who, along with the leaking FBI officials, was also the source of the media articles.
1. Steele —> Media(Yahoo/Wapo/NYT/CNN/MJ)
2. FBI —> Media
3. Steele/Media FBI —> FISC
4. Media Steele/FBI(#1, #2) —> FISC
This is a circle of information, all coming from Glenn Simpson at Fusion GPS, who was the opposition research firm being financed by Hillary Clinton, along with FBI officials who were using their own strategic leaks to validate their own investigation.
You are, of course, right, but you have to take what facts you can get from them. To find those documented instances when they tell the truth is like finding a needle in the haystack, but, hey, don’t throw it back….use it to pin the truth up for all to see.
Nixon was pardoned by presidential decree, for his proven high crimes and TREASON.
the left (who or what is unimportant) will never listen or read a long list of FACTS.
the golf bum and his krew must do the time for the crimes, or the 911 redo will begin again.
the left will go insane if anyone touches hillary or bath house Barry.
let the fight begin today and GET IT OVER, so our kids don’t have to do it again and again .
I really think Trump is giving he life…literally to do what he can for us.
is it to little to late?
Most likely. No reason for us to give up and roll over dead though!
how to stop worrying and love the bomb?
Without the FREE net there is little we can learn or do! We become even MORE like cattle in the slaughter chute!
how did the paki get the fcc?
just an accident?
Federal Communications Commission (FCC) ??? U talkin about Debbie’s 4 Paki IT boys who do hit’s on the side when they are not workin at McDonalds and responsible for ALL Congressional Democrats IT ?
somebody appointed a third world person from Pakistan to lead the FCC , then the changes began for the Internet .I have little hope for a free internet in the future here unless it goes underground somehow..
I thought the guy with the funny name was fightin the fairness doctrine which supposedly is AGAINST fairness and for censorship.
maybe they lie a LOT.
In da End Times tellin da Truth is a Revolutionary Act!
maybe surrender ON TERMS?
did not work very well at the ALAMO.lol
Never surrender nor Renounce Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior and NEVER take the Mark of da BEAST!
Nixon was taken out by the Globalist ‘Deep State” for his desire to place high tariffs to protect American Manufacturing goods. This gave Rockefeller his green light to use Kissinger/Haig and the SS White House Captain to work with Congress to take him out. Follow these sums careers before and After Watergate. All Owned by Rockefeller!
his pardon was the real crime and it keeps on giving the poor citizens of the USA HELL.
The real crime is President Ford’s sittin on the Warren Commission and being recorded by the FBI telling Hoover that he and two other Warren Commission members were forced to say it was a lone gunman and a single bullet that wacked JFK!
so much is buried so deep , recovery is impossible.
the intent from the get go.
And much on the net which was easy to find on a search engine, especially Google, is being very deeply buried or even impossible to recover.
It definitely is 1984 on da Animal Farm in the Brave New World at a Toasty 451*F!
The MEMORY HOLE Lives!
Some interesting info brought to light by Sharyl Atkinson that has been overlooked:
The biggest of all BIGGER story aspects to the HPSCI Memo, in all coverage, has been overlooked by all Main Stream Media. The Department of Justice FBI FISA request was for “Title I” surveillance authority. This is not some innocuous request for metadata exploration – the FBI said American citizen Carter Page was a “foreign agent of a hostile foreign government”; the FBI was calling Carter Page a spy.
“Title I” FISA surveillance of U.S. citizens is the most intrusive, exhaustive and far reaching type of search, seizure and surveillance authority, permitting the FBI to look at every scintilla of Mr. Page’s life. All communication, travel and contact can be opened and reviewed. All aspects of any of Mr. Page’s engagements are subject to being secretly monitored. This is an entirely different level of surveillance authority, the highest possible, and has nothing to do with FISA-702 search queries (Title VII) of U.S. persons.
To present a methaphor, under Title I FISA authority, Carter Page was essentially ‘patient zero’ in an Ebola pandemic. Labeling him as a foreign agent allowed the FBI to look at every single person he came in contact with; and every single aspect of their lives and their activities in growing and concentric circles; without limits to current time or historic review.
The “Title I” designation as a foreign agent applied retroactively to any action taken by Mr. Page, and auto-generates an
exponential list of other people he came in contact with. Each of those people, groups or organizations could now have their communication reviewed, unmasked and analyzed by the DOJ/FBI with the same surveillance authority granted upon the target, Mr. Page.
Ron Paul: What the Fisa memo tells us about our government
22.214.171.124/.zh2.html (cut and paste the link if necessary)
Scroll down the page a little to find this nice take on the whole thing. The corruption seems to be a coordinated effort by both parties (which are actually just two sides of the same coin)