Stocks May Be Losing The Fight To Bonds Even If Yields Fall

by

For months, investors tolerated a 10-year Treasury yield climbing from around 4.17% to above 5%.

Stocks kept going.

That was the market saying higher yields were acceptable because earnings, AI spending and economic growth were strong enough to justify higher valuations.

Now watch what happens if that relationship flips again.

Stocks can start falling even while Treasury yields are falling.

That would be a much nastier signal.

Because then the market isn’t simply saying, “Rates are too high.”

It is saying, “I want out of stocks.”

There is already evidence that money is moving in that direction.

LSEG Lipper data showed U.S. equity funds suffered their fourth consecutive weekly outflow through September 18, with investors pulling $31.44 billion. Large-cap funds alone lost $28.71 billion.

At the same time, short-to-intermediate government and Treasury funds attracted $3.49 billion, their 11th straight week of inflows.

ICI data tells the same story from another angle.

For the week ending September 9, bond funds took in an estimated $11.55 billion, while equity funds lost $11.77 billion. That wasn’t a one-week accident either. Bond flows had been positive for weeks while domestic equity flows repeatedly ran negative.

That’s the part I’d pay attention to.

The money is already moving.

But there is a catch.

Investors aren’t piling into 20- or 30-year Treasuries yet.

Reuters reported that U.S. ETF investors have been favoring short and intermediate maturities while keeping demand for long-duration bond funds subdued. Short U.S. Treasury ETFs pulled in $12.2 billion over the 20 trading sessions through September 8, while intermediate-term bond ETFs attracted another $5.7 billion.

That tells you investors want the safety and income of government debt without making a huge bet on the long end.

Why?

Because the long end still has a problem.

The 10-year has been hovering around 5%, with inflation, oil, government borrowing and Treasury supply all pushing investors to demand more compensation for holding long-term debt. The 10-year recently reached 5%, its highest level since 2007.

So the market is caught between two trades.

Stocks have become expensive enough that investors are taking money off the table.

Long bonds aren’t yet trusted enough to receive all of it.

That can change very quickly if inflation pressure fades and the 10-year starts falling.

Then the math gets interesting.

Imagine the 10-year drops from 5% toward 4.5%.

Bond prices rise.

The income becomes more attractive.

The duration trade starts working.

And if stocks simultaneously stop responding positively to lower yields, you’ve got something much different from the old “higher rates kill stocks” trade.

You have money rotating out of equities while bonds are becoming the destination.

That is why the stock-bond correlation matters so much right now.

The San Francisco Fed recently documented that the relationship between stocks and Treasury yields has flipped into negative territory again, arguing that the change reflects a shift toward supply-side risks such as inflation and energy shocks.

Axios found that the negative correlation between S&P 500 returns and 10-year Treasury yields has reached some of its most extreme readings in decades.

And Reuters was still describing the stock market as remarkably resilient just days ago: the S&P 500 remained less than 3% below its August record despite the bond selloff and the 10-year approaching 5%.

That’s exactly why this setup is worth watching.

The market has already demonstrated that it can ignore 5% Treasury yields.

We don’t know yet whether it can ignore falling yields accompanied by falling stocks.

That is the test.

South Korea is giving us another version of it.

The KOSPI has repeatedly struggled around 7,000. It briefly broke above the level, then fell back as oil prices and U.S. Treasury yields rose. On September 11, it dropped back below 7,000 after the 10-year approached 5%.

And now the index is sitting around 6,894, only about 3% below 7,100.

So I wouldn’t make the prediction that Korea crashes.

I’d watch what happens when it reaches that ceiling again.

If yields fall and the KOSPI still can’t hold the breakout, while U.S. stocks also begin weakening, the message becomes much harder to dismiss.

The market would be telling us that lower yields are no longer automatically bullish for stocks.

That changes the trade completely.

Because if falling yields stop rescuing equities, the Fed becomes less relevant to the immediate market signal.

The 10-year becomes the tell.

And eventually the question becomes very simple:

Where does the money go when investors stop wanting stocks?

Right now, some of it is already going into Treasuries.

The next thing to watch is whether that trickle becomes a rotation.

Not financial advice.

Got a news tip or correction? Let us know

If you got something out of this, please chip in to keep this site running, or subscribe to go ad-free.

0 views