Is Europe and its economy in decline?

via notayesmanseconomics

This morning Dr.Isabel Schnabel of the ECB has been speaking in Lithuania and she is both a bell-weather for ECB opinion as well as being prone to statements like this.

In this polarised world, Europe is often portrayed as a continent in decline, squeezed between geopolitical rivals, held back by excessive regulation and struggling to keep pace with rapid technological change.

In my remarks this morning, I will argue that although this narrative is appealing in its simplicity, it is misleading.

If you like this is a case of never believe anything until it is officially denied. This echoes what has been her most significant speech of all back on February 19th 2024 when her rhetoric about how well the Euro was doing collided with a reality of substantial under performance compared to the United States.That speech was however the first time the Euro area establishment accepted that there were economic issues and led to the Draghi Review.However just like his time as ECB President when the press conferences called for economic reform real world action has been thin on the ground. Whereas only yesterday we saw that even us lazy Brexiter Brits have in fact managed to find some economic growth on the back of the AI wave.

In fact this is symbolised by the next part of the speech which is rather familiar and similar to what she said on February 19th 2024.

By many measures, Europe is among the regions with the highest quality of life, grounded in strong institutions, a high degree of social protection and an exceptional capacity to adapt in times of crisis.

In that vein it is hard not to have a wry smile at this.

Against this backdrop, Europe’s continued commitment to democracy, the rule of law and institutional checks and balances underpin trust and policy credibility, while independent media ensure accountability and transparency.

What has gone wrong then?

A metric popular in the comments section gets a mention.

they have also weighed on GDP per capita, adjusted for the cost of living, which is one of the most used indicators of economic prosperity..By this measure, the euro area ranks below other advanced economies.

Seeing as the Euro area was supposed to be a weapon for economic prosperity some might consider this to be quite a flaw. There is also rather a swerve in there which is highlighted by the way she throws Eastern Europe under the bus.

Part of this difference reflects the fact that some euro area economies are still catching up, mainly in eastern Europe. These countries are mostly growing rapidly, but their incomes remain below the euro area average, which dampens the headline number.

We have switched to levels which rather obscures the relative performance of Europe in the Euro area era. Even worse the areas which have seen the performance wanted “growing rapidly” find themselves taking the rap.

The issues are apparently threefold.

First, a large part of the gap in income levels reflects less work rather than less productive work. On average, an employee in the United States works around 40 days more per year than an employee in the euro area.

This is both good and bad with the former being a chance perhaps for a better work/life balance. But we are also seeing part of why the US economy has done better especially if we add in the mention of more investment from her February 2024 speech.Indeed we get another perspective from this morning’s official release as we know US GDP rose by 0.8% in the third quarter.

In the third quarter of 2026, seasonally adjusted GDP increased by 0.4% in the euro area and by 0.5% in the EU, compared with the previous quarter, according to a flash estimate published by Eurostat, the statistical office of the European Union.

Along the way we see the EU has done better than the Euro area when it was supposed to be the other way around. But the main theme is that Euro GDP growth is half that of the US even if we do not adjust for the Ireland which saw GDP growth of 5.5%. Later on Dr.Isabel inadvertently critiques this with the bit I have highlighted.

Ireland, meanwhile, has become a global hotspot for technology, pharmaceutical and life science companies. It is one of the most efficient countries in which to do business and it has the highest share of tertiary students in natural sciences, mathematics and statistics fields in the EU.

Also the problem with the argument below comes from the 2012 Euro area crisis when the establishment ran the theme of southern Europeans in general and Greeks in particular being lazy.

A simple counterfactual shows that if Europeans were to work as many hours as Americans, holding productivity per hour and the employment rate constant, euro area real GDP per capita would be 21% higher.[7] That would close about two-thirds of the current real income gap with the United States.

So to misquote Slade oh mama we are all lazy now…..

Next up is this.

Second, growth in Europe is more inclusive.

Which boils down to something familiar from inflation numbers as we exclude things that are rising fast.

Since 2000, more than a quarter of total growth in value added per employee in the United States has accrued in the information and communications technology sector – an industry that accounts for less than 2% of total employment.

Now this is more than a little awkward because her landmark speech in February 2024 was in essence about trying to get the growth this sector has provided. Has she given up on that? Anyway if you exclude the best bits in thee US then Europe and the US are the same.

As the exceptional expansion of large technology companies has been concentrated in a small number of US states, the growth performance of the typical state has been more modest, even as aggregate US GDP per capita has surged.

Indeed, growth in real GDP per capita in the median US state and that in the median euro area country have evolved largely in lockstep.

Some research student will have got a pat on the back for this torturing of the numbers.This does not mean that all in the AI garden is rosy as we were discussing in the comments section only yesterday the risks for employment. But at least the US has an AI garden

Point three rather contradicts point two as in essence the Euro area has failed.

But to protect these advantages, Europe needs sustained growth. And this growth is threatened by persistently weak productivity growth in the euro area – the third dimension.

Over the past three decades, output per hour worked has risen more slowly than in several peer economies, reflecting less capital deepening, smaller firms and the lack of diffusion of new technologies

Southern Europeans

This part is incredibly awkward for the European establishment as look what those they castigated as lazy have done.

According to the European Commission, potential growth in Spain, Portugal and Greece is projected to be measurably higher than the euro area average in the years to come.

Also notice how we have switched from the absolutes and levels of the start to potential now. That saves having to point out that Greece has yet to get back to where it started from. But they have had better growth and I wish them well.

Comment

There are two more major issues with this.

A 28th regime can change that.[26]

The concept is simple: under a 28th regime, a company could choose to incorporate as a genuinely European firm, which the European Commission refers to as “EU Inc.

However badly it performs in reality the answer is always more Europe. Andrea True Connection.

(More, more, more)
How do you like it? How do you like it?
(More, more, more)
How do you like it? How do you like it?
(More, more, more)
How do you like it? How do you like it?

There would be gains from a unified approach if they did not spoil them with bureaucracy and regulation.

The next issue boils down to one word.

Spain, for example, has emerged as a European leader in renewable energy. This has significantly reduced wholesale electricity prices and the country’s vulnerability to global energy price shocks, transforming it into a European hub for the energy-intensive industries of the future.

If it was the success claimed the word wholesale would not be required in front of electricity prices.

Got a news tip or correction? Let us know

If you got something out of this, please chip in to keep this site running, or subscribe to go ad-free.

1 view