From Birch Gold Group
Hurricane Harvey isn’t done yet. First it hit the Gulf Coast, then it hit Hollywood (Harvey Weinstein)…
And now it’s hitting Harvey, Illinois, a town of 25,000, in the form of a major pension crisis that includes laying off 40% of its firefighters.
That is just the tip of the iceberg, because Illinois State law doesn’t allow the town to file bankruptcy or manage its own way out of the precarious situation.
According to a report at American Thinker, it almost seems as if Illinois is in a “pension dream land” that doesn’t want to solve the problem:
The Illinois Opportunity Project has long been an advocate for reforming the pension system and shifting state-funded pensions to a 401k style system. Politicians have proven time and time again that they are unable to manage the funds and have succumbed to pressures from public sector unions to overpromise benefits, thus enabling an unsustainable system at the state and local levels at the expense of hard working taxpayers. …
State lawmakers have no other choice but to enact legislation to allow local units of government to file for bankruptcy. The state must loosen its reins over local governments and allow them to reform their finances, otherwise everyone suffers and Illinois will continue to lead the nation in outbound residents seeking to escape a confiscatory government.
In a city with 20% unemployment, property tax rates over 5%, and home values declining by 80% over the last decade, you would think solving economic problems would be high on its list.
It might be, but greed and incompetence from the city government seem to have higher priority… at the cost of Harvey residents.
Any “math” that includes low revenue and higher pension costs doesn’t work that well. In fact, the whole State might suffer while you foot part of the bill…
Harvey’s Pension Problems Serve as a “Canary in the Coal Mine”
Harvey is a small town, but if the behavior of city and State officials “handling” this pension crisis gives any clue… the whole State’s pension system might be in jeopardy.
Government and financial watchdog Ted Dabrowski reports:
The reality is Harvey might be only the tip of the iceberg. A growing number of Illinois cities and villages are approaching Harvey’s dire situation.
More than half of Illinois’ 651 municipal public safety funds are funded at rates below 60 percent, Dabrowski pointed out in a recent blog post.
Since the State of Illinois doesn’t allow cities to file bankruptcy on pension debt, each fund has to be “paid.” So Harvey has to cough up tax revenue to pay down their pension debt to the State.
But the funds aren’t there, and robbing Peter to pay Paul can only last so long.
And if we extrapolate this out to the other cities with similar pension problems, the outlook is dire. According to Fox Business, the city officials don’t know how they are going to make ends meet…
Harvey officials said Tuesday they will lay off more than three dozen employees.
“We are in a situation where basically monies were taxed, they were collected and the police pension and the fire pension weren’t paid,” Alderman Christopher Clark said Thursday to FOX Business’ Jeff Flock. “As a result now the [state] comptrollers held that money… from the city of Harvey, Illinois, and we don’t know how we are going to make payroll and other city services.”
Add in the other city pensions suffering similar fates, and this could lead to an entire State-wide collapse of the pension system. Retirees could lose all of their retirement benefits. Which begs the question…
How many city employees will have to suffer before the State of Illinois realizes that they need to change policy, and that pensions are an outdated retirement vehicle?
Based on the reaction so far, public employees in Illinois should be worried. Anyone in the State with a public pension plan should be terrified.
Writing for Illinois Policy, Adam Schuster sums up the dire “hurricane” of pension challenges for the entire State nicely:
The story of Harvey should be a cautionary tale for the state of Illinois as a whole. The unfunded pension liability for state pension funds — to say nothing of local pension debt such as Harvey’s — is between $130 billion and $250 billion…
This problem is mirrored in local governments across the state, where hundreds of millions of dollars in additional taxpayer contributions have not been able to keep up with the rapid growth in pension benefits.
The pension crisis unfolding in Harvey, IL and state-wide serve as a stark warning to State and city governments across the country…
State Pensions Across the U.S. are Ticking Time Bombs
We’ve covered pension problems before, including those in other states, but in 2018 the whole facade might just come crumbling down.
According to a mid-2017 report by Benjamin Smith over at Lombardi, all 50 states might experience profound pension challenges…
A study of the 649 different pension systems around the United States found systematic problems with the assumptions underlying many trusts, which is now coming to a head. This will have profound effects on citizens of all 50 states, as pension promises go unfulfilled and pressures build on governments to increase taxes. In short, a pension crisis is in the works.
The “crisis in the works” from that report is unfolding in 2018. Harvey and New Jersey are just the tip of the iceberg. In fact, only one state in the U.S. (Wisconsin) ran a pension surplus.
According to 2012 U.S. Census Bureau data analyzed by NerdWallet, 37 of 50 state pension plans were underfunded. Several states were in the “likely to default” category (see map below, source).
Six years after this was published, almost every single state in the Union has an “unbalanced budget due to runaway pension costs” according to Forbes.
And upon reviewing the 2017 Edition of the Hoover Hidden Debt, Hidden Deficits report, it looks like States aren’t exactly reporting the full truth.
In fact, it looks like outdated State pension plans are eating up the tax revenue of their respective state budgets faster than a pie-eating champion gobbling pies in grandma’s kitchen.
Here’s a look at the first page of the entire Hoover report you can get here, and notice the second paragraph…
So as this “hidden debt” keeps eating away at state budgets without being accounted for… eventually you might end up footing the tax bill to aid in recovery.
The money has to come from somewhere, but that doesn’t mean you can’t put yours in the right places.
How Gold Can Help Protect Your Retirement From the Ravages of “Hurricane Harvey”…
As the outdated pension system implodes, it might be a good idea to diversify some of your retirement fund into a Precious Metals IRA.
By doing so, you may be able to avoid the headaches caused by the next “Harvey” in your own State.