It’s amazing to review the Bank of America fund manager survey’s question on the most crowded trade because it would have been a money maker if the results would have come out earlier. As you can see from the chart below, it became even more of a consensus that the long US treasuries trade was very crowded.
BAML Fund manager survey: Long US Treasuries the most crowded trade. pic.twitter.com/J8vQqdJRyo
— Jai Jeswani (@jjeswani) September 17, 2019
This survey gave you a hint a big reversal was coming in August as over 30% of fund managers stated this was the most crowded trade. Right before the selloff in treasuries last week, the survey showed that percentage getting near 40.
Similarly, this survey was correct in saying long growth stocks was a crowded trade as there was a big pop in the ratio of value to growth stocks as the financials and energy stocks rallied in the first half of September. Obviously, it’s way easier to point out an overcrowded trade than it is to get in the trenches and bet against it because betting against a trend takes great timing. If you mistime the trade, you can lose money. It’s easier to do from the sidelines. That’s not to say there’s no value in avoiding overcrowded trades. Just staying out of the way can be a big win. Timing is less of an issue here.
Expecting A Trade Deal Is Non-Consensus
The latest news on trade appears to be positive as China and America will meet in mid-October. One potential negative not covered in the media is that China may have exempted tariffs on pork and soybeans because food prices are soaring not because of goodwill. It’s debatable if that’s good or bad because on the one hand, it means China isn’t changing its stance on trade. On the other hand, did we really expect China to change its perspective out of kindness? It’s all about economics.
When do you think the trade war will be resolved?
Answer: never pic.twitter.com/VTt8RtNBUN
— Jai Jeswani (@jjeswani) September 17, 2019
Fund managers aren’t optimistic on trade, making the expectation of a deal a non-consensus play. You have the opportunity to make money if you are correct on this. To outperform the market, you need to go against the consensus at inflection points. However, to go against the consensus successfully, you need really good research. The trade war was considered the biggest tail risk in this survey. However, it fell from getting about 50% of the vote to about 40%. As you can see from the chart above, over 35% of managers think the U.S. China trade war is the new normal which won’t be resolved. Only less than 5% see it being resolved this year. 25% say a deal will be made before the US presidential election in 2020.
Managers Chase US Stocks
Cash levels fell from 5.7% in June to 4.7% in September as managers might be chasing equities. They are chasing US stocks in particular. As you can see in the chart below, allocation to US stocks increased 15 points to 17% overweight. That’s the biggest jump since June 2018.
% OW US +15% to 17%. Just in time. pic.twitter.com/qonZDvbjwX
— Teddy Vallee (@TeddyVallee) September 17, 2019
When over 15% of managers are overweight US stocks, US stocks fall 25.2% annually.
GDP Could Turn Negative
The Cass Freight index was weak again in August. Cass Information Systems stated, “we see a growing risk that GDP will go negative by year’s end.” This is because the shipments index is “signaling an economic contraction.” The results weren’t good even though the shipments index had 1.6% monthly growth. This report isn’t seasonally adjusted so we look closer at yearly growth.
This was the 9th straight negative yearly volume growth reading as the chart below shows.
Cass Freight Index – Shipments pic.twitter.com/fitnRsMJF2
— Don Draper (@DonDraperClone) September 13, 2019
Yearly growth improved from -5.9% in July to -3%. That improvement only occurred because the comp fell from 10.6% to 6%. In other words, the 2 year growth stack fell. It went from 4% to 2.8%. On the other hand, tough comps make the 6% decline in May, which was the worst in this expansion, look better than it was. The 2 year growth stack isn’t as bad as the 2016 low just yet.
The expenditures index was similarly bad. Its yearly growth rate fell from -1.4% to -2.6% which is the worst reading since December 2016. Its comps are tougher which is why its 2 year growth stack is still very high. However, the 2 year stack is dropping quickly as it went from 27.7% in December to 16.3% in July to 13.6% in August.
Chinese Rhetoric & Expectations Don’t Match PMI
The Chinese Premier signaled more pessimism than the recent PMI report showed. Li Kreqiang stated “For China to maintain growth of 6% or more is very difficult against the current backdrop of a complicated international situation and a relatively high base, and this rate is at the forefront of the world’s leading economies.” He blamed the global slowdown and protectionism (the trade war).
It’s ironic to see China blame the global slowdown since China is one of the main drivers of said slowdown. Morgan Stanley believes 2019 GDP growth will be near the low end of the government’s expected range of 6% to 6.5%. It’s sounds like it’s based on the Premier’s rhetoric. This isn’t in line with the August Caixin PMI which improved from 50.9 to 51.6 because of improvements in services and manufacturing. Services increased from 51.6 to 52.1 and manufacturing from 49.9 to 50.4.
The Empire Fed manufacturing report showed big weakness in 6 month expectations. The current index fell from 4.8 to 2 as the new orders and shipments indexes fell 3.2 and 3.5 points to 3.5 and 5.8. The big sequential decline was in expectations as the forward general business conditions index fell 12 points to 13.7. The new orders and shipments indexes fell near their 2016 lows. They fell 9.8 and 10.7 points to 21.9 and 20.4. As you can see from the chart below, the technology spending and capex indexes cratered. They fell 10.9 and 18.6 points to 6.5 and 4.6.
— Bespoke (@bespokeinvest) September 16, 2019
Fund managers were right about treasuries and growth stocks being overcrowded as treasuries have sold off and value has outperformed growth recently. Fund managers have been chasing U.S. equities, but they aren’t optimistic about a trade deal soon. The Cass Freight index shows the level of economic weakness is getting closer to the 2015 to 2016 slowdown. Cass Information Systems already sees the possibility of negative GDP growth later this year. The Empire Fed manufacturing expectations index showed weakness possibly because of the trade war.